Skip to content
Adventure Theory
When to Walk Away. Man, We're in Trouble! with Mitch, Ed and Billy

When to Walk Away

Mitch and Ed sit down with their longtime friend Billy, who left the Army after 12 years as an infantry officer, to talk about knowing when to walk away from a career and what life after the military really feels like.

By Mitchell Phelps on , 2 min read

Want to listen on other platforms? Click here.

When do you walk away from something you spent your whole life working toward? Mitch and Ed sit down with Billy, a friend since their college days, who served 12 years as an Army infantry officer: Ranger tab, two company commands, and a plan he'd had since he was a kid. He talks through the dream that didn't pan out, the morning in command when he knew he was done, and why getting out turned out to be so much harder than he expected. It's an honest, sometimes funny talk about leadership, guilt, sunk costs, and learning that calling it quits isn't the same as giving up.

In this episode

00:00 Welcome: Billy joins Mitch and Ed

00:39 Billy's story: 12 years in the Army, and still in transition

04:48 Going deep: when did the Army stop being a career?

05:12 Following his father into the Army

07:46 "After the Army? Is there an after the Army?"

09:58 The selection invite that never came

14:35 A rough stretch, and finding purpose as an instructor

16:03 Did command live up to the hype? Some of the best people he ever served with

17:51 Leadership, rules and pointless trenches

19:09 Decisions made for bullet points on your military resume

20:38 The morning that ended it: "You're rogue. You're not fit for the Army."

31:31 The apology, the farewell party, and "I quit"

34:26 Getting out with zero preparation

36:30 Chasing the team-leader feeling one more time

38:30 Keeping a relationship going from the other side of the world

39:49 From 100 miles per hour to a brick wall

45:21 Guilt, and wrestling with going back in

48:31 Sunk cost and the slot machine

54:42 Advice to his past self: make a plan, and let go

58:50 If you're going through a big change, reach out to somebody

Heard on the show

"When I was in the Army, I was driving a hundred miles per hour. And then the day I got out, I felt like I all of a sudden hit a brick wall." (Billy)

"I haven't won yet. Let me put one more coin in the slot machine." (Ed)

"Sometimes you just gotta call it quits, and that's not giving up." (Ed)

"If you're going through a rough time, just reach out to somebody. It may not change anything, but maybe it at least helps you mentally and emotionally." (Billy)

Liked it? Follow and share the show, and tell us what we should talk about next.

Mitchell Phelps

Mitchell Phelps

Hey there, I'm Mitch Phelps. For the past 15 years, I've been immersed in the art of photography, always striving to tell stories through my lens. I'm deeply inspired by the environment and the diverse cultures we encounter along the way, and I aim to capture that. As a dedicated Sony shooter, I'm always eager to push creative boundaries. If you're interested in connecting or collaborating, feel free to reach out!

Keep exploring

Men Don't Feel Heard. Man, We're in Trouble! with Mitch and Ed

Podcast

Men Don't Feel Heard

Mitch and Ed talk about why men stop opening up, what happens when vulnerability gets used against them, and whether women really are attracted to men in caregiving jobs.

Zero to Stepdad. Man, We're in Trouble! with Mitch, Ed and Matt

Podcast

Zero to Stepdad

Mitch and Ed talk with Matt, who landed a new job, moved, got engaged and is about to become a stepdad before ever living with his fiancée, about handling big life changes as a team.

It's Not a Zero Sum Game. Man, We're in Trouble! with Mitch and Ed

Podcast

It's Not a Zero Sum Game

Mitch and Ed debate whether women secretly benefit from the patriarchy, and end up talking about the pay gap, dating up, why young men fall for the red pill, and why boys are left to figure out their feelings alone.